Evidence
What each party said, when relevant source content changed, and what the archive classified as collection-only differences. 134 snapshots across 59 registered web sources preserve 45 reviewed source-content changes. Substantive claims elsewhere on the site link to these evidence records.
The archive also preserves 24 collection differences caused by capture-method corrections or dynamic page chrome. 5 detected differences currently await review.
Organisational statements and documentation
First-party advisories, documentation, terms and service records from organisations responsible for the product or service discussed.
- Entropy technical backgrounder coinkite-backgrounder Coinkite
Vendor advisory 3 snapshots
source change 1 Aug 2026, 18:44 UTC checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:57 UTC - Mk3 security advisory coinkite-mk3-advisory Coinkite
Vendor advisory 5 snapshots
source change 1 Aug 2026, 18:44 UTC checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:57 UTC - Coinkite blog index coinkite-blog-index Coinkite
Vendor publication index 2 snapshots
source change 1 Aug 2026, 14:02 UTC checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:57 UTC - COLDCARD firmware downloads coldcard-downloads Coinkite
Firmware release index 2 snapshots
source change 1 Aug 2026, 14:02 UTC checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:57 UTC - MARA Slipstream transaction-submission portal mara-slipstream-portal MARA
Vendor documentation 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:57 UTC - MARA Slipstream API documentation mara-slipstream-api MARA
Vendor documentation 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:57 UTC - Coinkite terms of sale coinkite-terms Coinkite
Legal terms 2 snapshots
source change 1 Aug 2026, 16:08 UTC checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:58 UTC - Debian Security Advisory DSA-1571-1 debian-openssl-dsa-1571 Debian
Vendor advisory 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:59 UTC - Some SecureRandom thoughts android-securerandom-2013 Android Developers
Vendor statement 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:59 UTC - BitBox is not affected bitbox-not-affected BitBox
Vendor statement 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:59 UTC - Jade is unaffected jade-not-affected Blockstream
Vendor statement 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:59 UTC - Passport is not affected passport-not-affected Foundation
Vendor statement 2 snapshots
source change 1 Aug 2026, 16:09 UTC checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:59 UTC - COLDCARD entropy FAQ coldcard-docs-faq Coinkite
Vendor documentation 2 snapshots
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 01:00 UTC - Coinkite's pre-incident paper-spam warning coinkite-paper-spam Coinkite
Vendor statement 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 01:00 UTC
Legislation
Official government statute pages used for legal context. Inclusion identifies the text checked and does not determine how it applies to a particular claim.
- Consumer Protection Act, 2002 ontario-consumer-protection-act-2002 Ontario e-Laws
Government legislation 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:58 UTC - Consumer Protection Act, 2023 ontario-consumer-protection-act-2023 Ontario e-Laws
Government legislation 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:58 UTC
Public vulnerability records
Government-maintained vulnerability records used to identify published technical details and affected-version ranges.
Primary technical research
Original analysis by people who read the code or the chain themselves, rather than reporting on somebody who did. Credited individually on the analysis page.
- Predictable RNG fallback and 32-bit reseed block-disclosure Block
Primary technical research 2 snapshots
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:58 UTC - Mk3 binary reversal and bounded proof of concept threez-mk3-rng-disclosure 3z
Independent primary analysis 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:58 UTC - Chain-derived COLDCARD RNG postmortem kelbie-rng-postmortem Kelbie
Independent primary analysis 3 snapshots
source change 1 Aug 2026, 17:12 UTC checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:59 UTC - Reproducible firmware and chain investigation alvap-weak-rng-research Álvaro P.
Independent primary analysis 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:59 UTC - Disclosure of vulnerable Bitcoin wallet library unciphered-randstorm-disclosure Unciphered
Primary technical research 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:59 UTC - Milk Sad vulnerability disclosure milksad-disclosure Milk Sad research team
Primary technical research 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:59 UTC - Wizardsardine post-mortem and user guidance wizardsardine-postmortem Wizardsardine
Independent primary analysis 2 snapshots
source change 1 Aug 2026, 19:47 UTC checked 2 Aug 2026, 01:00 UTC - Dettmer commit-history analysis of the entropy bug btcpp-dettmer-commit-history bitcoin++ Insider Edition
Independent primary analysis 2 snapshots
source change 1 Aug 2026, 22:25 UTC checked 2 Aug 2026, 01:00 UTC - End-to-end reproduction of the affected generator dk27ss-poc-readme DK27ss
Independent primary analysis 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 01:00 UTC - Collision demonstration and firmware guard scanner nobuxpt-entropy-test-readme nobuxpt
Independent primary analysis 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 01:00 UTC
Secondary analysis
Technical interpretation and guidance built from primary disclosures or other researchers. Useful, but one step removed from the original finding.
- Who must move their coins tftc-who-must-move TFTC
Secondary analysis 2 snapshots
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:59 UTC - Bitcoin Optech Newsletter #416 optech-416 Bitcoin Optech
Secondary analysis 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 01:00 UTC - COLDCARD Mk3 entropy reference keychainx-reference KeychainX
Secondary analysis 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 01:00 UTC
Repository files and pull requests
Release notes, source files and the upstream fixes proposed after disclosure. Mostly append-only sources preserved for source-level context.
- COLDCARD firmware changelog cc-changelog Coinkite
Repository file 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:57 UTC - Mk3 firmware history cc-history-mk3 Coinkite
Repository file 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:57 UTC - Mk4 and Mk5 firmware history cc-history-mk Coinkite
Repository file 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:57 UTC - Q firmware history cc-history-q Coinkite
Repository file 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:58 UTC - libngu random.c libngu-random-c switck
Repository file 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:58 UTC - libngu PR #58 libngu-pr-58 switck
Repository pull request 3 snapshots
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:58 UTC - libngu PR #58 patch libngu-pr-58-patch switck
Repository patch 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:58 UTC - libngu PR #59 libngu-pr-59 switck
Repository pull request 3 snapshots
source change 1 Aug 2026, 16:08 UTC checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:58 UTC - libngu PR #59 patch libngu-pr-59-patch switck
Repository patch 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:58 UTC - libngu PR #60: full-width reseeding libngu-pr-60 switck
Repository pull request 3 snapshots
source change 1 Aug 2026, 17:41 UTC checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:58 UTC - libngu PR #60 patch libngu-pr-60-patch switck
Repository patch 2 snapshots
source change 1 Aug 2026, 16:08 UTC checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:58 UTC - COLDCARD firmware PR #691: pass the full secure-element digest coldcard-firmware-pr-691 Coinkite
Repository pull request 4 snapshots
source change 1 Aug 2026, 17:41 UTC checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:58 UTC - COLDCARD firmware PR #691 patch coldcard-firmware-pr-691-patch Coinkite
Repository patch 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:58 UTC - COLDCARD firmware PR #689: Mk3 RNG hotfix coldcard-firmware-pr-689 Coinkite
Repository pull request 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:58 UTC - COLDCARD firmware PR #689 patch coldcard-firmware-pr-689-patch Coinkite
Repository patch 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:58 UTC - COLDCARD firmware PR #690: Edge RNG hotfix coldcard-firmware-pr-690 Coinkite
Repository pull request 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:58 UTC - COLDCARD firmware PR #690 patch coldcard-firmware-pr-690-patch Coinkite
Repository patch 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:58 UTC - COLDCARD mainline RNG hotfix commit ca724637 coldcard-firmware-mainline-hotfix Coinkite
Repository commit 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:58 UTC - Bitcoin.org PR #4905: remove COLDCARD listings bitcoinorg-pr-4905 Bitcoin.org
Repository pull request 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:58 UTC - SatSigner PR #468: entropy audit and hardening satsigner-pr-468 SatSigner
Repository pull request 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:58 UTC - SeedSigner PR #962: withdrawn camera-entropy hardening proposal seedsigner-pr-962 SeedSigner
Repository pull request 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:58 UTC - Mk3 bounded proof README at e17d833b threez-mk3-rng-disclosure-pinned 3z
Repository commit 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:58 UTC
Reporting
Coverage that relays and interprets the primary sources above. Useful, and one step removed from the finding.
- Coinkite releases fixed firmware bitcoinmag-fix-and-ai Bitcoin Magazine
Reporting 1 snapshot
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:59 UTC - Galaxy loss estimate reporting theblock-galaxy-total The Block
Reporting 6 snapshots
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:59 UTC - COLDCARD wallet drain report coin360-drain Coin360
Reporting 4 snapshots
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 01:00 UTC
Chain monitors
Community-run trackers that let anyone check an address against the known affected set. Live services rather than documents, so they have no publication date.
- COLDCARD funds flow monitor coldcard-watch community tracker
Chain monitor 6 snapshots
source change 1 Aug 2026, 17:43 UTC checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:59 UTC - COLDCARD hack tracker coldcard-hack-tracker community tracker
Chain monitor 30 snapshots
source change 2 Aug 2026, 00:11 UTC checked 2 Aug 2026, 00:59 UTC - Source of the community holdings tracker samsamskies-tracker-readme SamSamskies
Chain monitor 2 snapshots
no reviewed source change checked 2 Aug 2026, 01:00 UTC
First-hand accounts
People describing what happened to them. Not evidence of mechanism, and the only material here written by someone who lost money.
Registered posts
Social posts that shaped the research or response. Each has a local evidence record showing whether a text or image capture is actually held.
- Full accountability statement nvk-apology @nvk
Coinkite 4 capture artefacts held 31 Jul 2026, 15:42 UTC - Browser-extension WASM vulnerability thread trustwallet-wasm-update @TrustWallet
Trust Wallet 2 capture artefacts held 22 Apr 2023, 08:59 UTC - Initial attack-cost model llfourn-model @LLFOURN
independent 4 capture artefacts held 31 Jul 2026, 00:41 UTC - Attack-cost follow-up llfourn-followup @LLFOURN
independent 2 capture artefacts held 31 Jul 2026, 20:58 UTC - Multisig threshold warning kloaec-multisig @KLoaec
independent 2 capture artefacts held 31 Jul 2026, 21:18 UTC - Operator attribution report clay-attribution @clay_garrett
Block 3 capture artefacts held 31 Jul 2026, 17:42 UTC - Earlier-wave accounting thread clay-earlier-waves-thread @clay_garrett
Block 8 capture artefacts held 31 Jul 2026, 00:03 UTC - Unchained client guidance unchained-guidance @unchained
Unchained 2 capture artefacts held 31 Jul 2026, 03:44 UTC - Tentative Mk4 entropy model otaliptus-technical @otaliptus
independent 3 capture artefacts held 1 Aug 2026, 01:32 UTC - Multisig migration race benowhere-multisig-race @BEN0WHERE
independent 2 capture artefacts held 1 Aug 2026, 00:37 UTC - Galaxy flow-of-funds map glxyresearch-flow-map @glxyresearch
Galaxy Research 5 capture artefacts held 31 Jul 2026, 13:23 UTC - Later 45.9 BTC wave kevinkelbie-later-wave @KevinKelbie
independent 2 capture artefacts held 1 Aug 2026, 01:43 UTC - Preliminary sweep accounting robhamilton-preliminary-sweep @Rob1Ham
AnchorWatch 2 capture artefacts held 30 Jul 2026, 18:30 UTC - Pessimistic Mk4 scenario llfourn-2083312169316499663 @LLFOURN
independent 4 capture artefacts held 31 Jul 2026, 22:01 UTC - Time-stamped migration risk llfourn-2083375420721025313 @LLFOURN
independent 4 capture artefacts held 1 Aug 2026, 02:13 UTC - Correction to multisig guidance llfourn-2083298061250666721 @LLFOURN
independent 2 capture artefacts held 31 Jul 2026, 21:05 UTC - Emergency migration guidance darosior-emergency-guidance @darosior
independent 2 capture artefacts held 31 Jul 2026, 16:30 UTC - Independent hardware reproduction instagibbs-reproduction @theinstagibbs
independent 4 capture artefacts held 30 Jul 2026, 22:37 UTC - Early low-entropy hypothesis kloaec-early-hypothesis @KLoaec
independent 2 capture artefacts held 30 Jul 2026, 20:28 UTC - Layered security response dhruvbansal-ai-response @dhruvbansal
independent 6 capture artefacts held 31 Jul 2026, 18:43 UTC - Independent key-recovery confirmation praveenperera-independent-confirmation @PraveenPerera
independent 2 capture artefacts held 30 Jul 2026, 23:46 UTC - Reported reproduction cost praveenperera-reproduction-cost @PraveenPerera
independent 2 capture artefacts held 31 Jul 2026, 01:01 UTC - Multisig migration PSA robhamilton-multisig-psa @Rob1Ham
independent 2 capture artefacts held 31 Jul 2026, 15:37 UTC - Slipstream endorsement and caveat petertodd-slipstream-guidance @peterktodd
independent 2 capture artefacts held 31 Jul 2026, 15:54 UTC - Slipstream access-code offer portlandhodl-slipstream-access @PortlandHODL
independent 2 capture artefacts held 31 Jul 2026, 16:59 UTC - Urgent expanded-scope update coldcard-expanded-scope @COLDCARDwallet
Coinkite 2 capture artefacts held 31 Jul 2026, 11:37 UTC - Mk3 v4.2.0 availability update coldcard-mk3-hotfix-update @COLDCARDwallet
Coinkite 2 capture artefacts held 31 Jul 2026, 13:43 UTC - Edge hotfix availability update coldcard-edge-hotfix-update @COLDCARDwallet
Coinkite 2 capture artefacts held 31 Jul 2026, 16:54 UTC - Mk3 on-device proof timing instagibbs-reproduction-followup @theinstagibbs
independent 2 capture artefacts held 31 Jul 2026, 13:48 UTC - Benma: BIP85 downstream-wallet warning benma-bip85-warning @_benma_
independent 2 capture artefacts held 1 Aug 2026, 02:14 UTC - Kevin Loaec: BIP85 downstream-wallet warning kloaec-bip85-warning @KLoaec
independent 2 capture artefacts held 31 Jul 2026, 10:31 UTC - Reported Slipstream migration outcome portlandhodl-slipstream-outcome @PortlandHODL
independent 2 capture artefacts held 1 Aug 2026, 03:18 UTC - Multisig relay and script-disclosure analysis guillemet-multisig-relay-analysis @P3b7_
Ledger 2 capture artefacts held 31 Jul 2026, 21:20 UTC - Ledger not-affected response ledger-not-affected-response @Ledger
Ledger 2 capture artefacts held 31 Jul 2026, 16:16 UTC - Casa multisig response casa-incident-guidance @CasaHODL
Casa 2 capture artefacts held 31 Jul 2026, 16:04 UTC - Casa migration video and risk claim nneuman-casa-migration-video @Nneuman
Casa 2 capture artefacts held 31 Jul 2026, 18:20 UTC - Layered-security response, part 1 dhruvbansal-ai-response-part1 @dhruvbansal
independent 2 capture artefacts held 31 Jul 2026, 18:43 UTC - Layered-security response, part 2 dhruvbansal-ai-response-part2 @dhruvbansal
independent 2 capture artefacts held 31 Jul 2026, 18:43 UTC - OPENDIME entropy-incorporation test zherbert-opendime-entropy-test @zherbert
Foundation Devices 2 capture artefacts held 1 Aug 2026, 03:47 UTC - OPENDIME and TAPSIGNER scope response robhamilton-opendime-tapsigner-scope @Rob1Ham
independent 2 capture artefacts held 1 Aug 2026, 04:04 UTC - 99-roll migration guidance jamesob-dice-roll-guidance @jamesob
independent 2 capture artefacts held 31 Jul 2026, 14:17 UTC - Reader post with attached multisig webinar slide alwaysaimbig-multisig-webinar-question @alwaysaimbig
independent 5 capture artefacts held 1 Aug 2026, 02:04 UTC - COLDCARD Urgent Migration Appeal coldcard-urgent-migration-appeal @COLDCARDwallet
independent 2 capture artefacts held 1 Aug 2026, 11:21 UTC - KLoaec Mk4 Class Drain Report kloaec-mk4-class-drain-report @KLoaec
independent 2 capture artefacts held 1 Aug 2026, 12:29 UTC - KLoaec Wizardsardine Postmortem kloaec-wizardsardine-postmortem @KLoaec
independent 2 capture artefacts held 1 Aug 2026, 15:45 UTC - KLoaec Derived Feature Exposure kloaec-derived-feature-exposure @KLoaec
independent 2 capture artefacts held 1 Aug 2026, 15:47 UTC - Claygarrett Bitkey Initial Findings claygarrett-bitkey-initial-findings @clay_garrett
independent 2 capture artefacts held 1 Aug 2026, 16:09 UTC - Btcpp Dettmer Analysis Announcement btcpp-dettmer-analysis-announcement @btcinsider__
independent 2 capture artefacts held 1 Aug 2026, 16:35 UTC - Galaxy Research Third Wave Revision glxyresearch-third-wave-revision @glxyresearch
independent 2 capture artefacts held 1 Aug 2026, 18:38 UTC - Galaxy Research Methodology Disclaimer glxyresearch-methodology-disclaimer @glxyresearch
independent 2 capture artefacts held 1 Aug 2026, 18:38 UTC - Galaxy Research Firmware Block Boundary glxyresearch-firmware-block-boundary @glxyresearch
independent 2 capture artefacts held 1 Aug 2026, 18:38 UTC - Galaxy Research Attacker Holdings glxyresearch-attacker-holdings @glxyresearch
independent 2 capture artefacts held 1 Aug 2026, 18:38 UTC - Galaxy Research Same Operator Basis glxyresearch-same-operator-basis @glxyresearch
independent 2 capture artefacts held 1 Aug 2026, 18:38 UTC - Lopp Scam Playbook Update lopp-scam-playbook-update @lopp
independent 3 capture artefacts held 1 Aug 2026, 18:02 UTC - Lopp Phishing Prediction lopp-phishing-prediction @lopp
independent 2 capture artefacts held 31 Jul 2026, 14:59 UTC